| Pos | Athlete | School | Gr | Mark |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Vito Luster | Wisconsin Lutheran | — | 1:02.52a |
| 2 | Finley Gospodarek | Wisconsin Lutheran | — | 1:03.27a |
| 3 | Joey Gu | Wisconsin Lutheran | — | 1:03.75a |
| 4 | Blake Nommensen | Wisconsin Lutheran | — | 1:04.31a |
| 6 | Deon Petty | Wisconsin Lutheran | — | 1:08.17a |
| 7 | Thomas Reuling | Wisconsin Lutheran | — | 1:10.21a |
| 8 | Max Perkins | Wisconsin Lutheran | — | 1:17.39a |
| 9 | Michael Guster | Pius XI Catholic | — | 1:19.44a |
| 10 | Christian Thomas | Pius XI Catholic | — | 1:24.69a |
